 | EUROPE'S MOST VISITED SF/F WEB SITE |
| Challenging
Destiny issue 18 - July 2004 check out website: www.Crystallinesphere.com and www.fictionwise.com
Despite some technical
merit existing in its presentation, the art on the cover wasn't relevant or interesting.
This was a pity because I think electronic magazines present great potential for
sharp, colourful images which don't cost a lot to reproduce but this was a run
of the mill thing you would see in 'Analog' or 'Magazine Of Fantasy & Science
Fiction'. Never fear, it gets a lot worse. The magazine has an editorial, five stories, a review and an interview. Let's have a look at the good work first before the demolition job can begin. 'The Miller And The Old Hag' was a quaint and well-written fairy story told in a style reminiscent of Hans Christian Anderson. Enjoyable to read, it enticed me to move on from one paragraph to the next to see what would happen. The author seems to have the skill to write a well-balanced story.
Also of some merit was the story about electronic implants by L. Blunt
Jackson called 'Early Adopters'. Though I was slightly confused on a couple of
occasions, probably more due to whisky than anything else, on the whole this was
a good tale with strong characters. I hope the future doesn't end up like this!
Jackson shows us the beginnings of mankind turning into machines. James
Schellenberg presented us with a competent review of everything to do with Frankenstein.
Most will be familiar with many of the movies mentioned here but will we agree
with Schellenberg's opinions? Personally, I thought Branagh's version was very
good. The interview with Karin Lowachee was boring. The questions were unimaginative, the format lacked surprise and the content came up with nothing spectacular. I was quite glad to get to the end of this piece. Now, the other stories. 'The Man Who Mistook Himself For A Super-Hero' by Karl El-koura began promisingly enough when a man awoke in an alleyway to find he had amnesia and super-powers. However, the idea wasn't developed to its potential and fell
flat on its face at the end. Rather disappointing. Similarly, 'Dead Man With A
Stick' from Greg Beatty, a story about primitive deities, was without much point
and also incomprehensible. I don't know what this story was trying to tell me. Saving the most vehement criticisms to the last, I can truthfully say that
'Benedice Te' by Jay Lake was one of the worst short stories I have ever read.
It was also quite derogatory to the British in particular. Written by an American
and edited by a Canadian, I have no wonder now why the gulf across the Atlantic
is widening on a daily basis. I also wonder at the standards of education over
there. This story was set in 1961 in a sort of alternative reality where the British hadn't lost the American part of its empire which became the United States in our dimension. The world, apparently unable to advance
much without the dynamism of the United States, is stuck in a type of Victorian
iron and steam age where everyone who isn't a true Brit is a varying type of 'wog'.
I don't think the author knows what a wog is, knows much about history and hasn't
a clue about the British. Stereotypical rubbish, that's what we have here. Apart from the above criticism, the story itself lacks cohesion and is
presented in a rather garbled way. What was his reason for writing it? I couldn't
think of one valid reason. Worse still, editor David M. Switzer thought this overlong
abusive tripe was worthy enough to open the batting. Speaks volumes for his ability
as an editor. Rod MacDonald
|
OTHER REVIEWS - September 2004
| ||||||||
A
Canadian eZine purporting to be 'New Fantasy & Science Fiction' is the subject
of this review. Issue number 18? I must confess not to have read the previous
seventeen issues but if they are anything as bad as this offering then it's a
miracle that the magazine has lasted so long.
 | |
| nest home | search engine | site directory | library | tools | about us | | |
| |
... www.sfcrowsnest.com © 2004 CWant a ? Then send an e-mail to: hologramtales-subscribe@topica.com